A user account is required in order to edit this wiki, but we've had to disable public user registrations due to spam.
To request an account, ask an autoconfirmed user on Chat (such as one of these permanent autoconfirmed members).
Cite element: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
(→opinions: Added my opinion) |
||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
* ... | * ... | ||
=== | === Opinions === | ||
Opinions on whether HTML5 should explicitly permit and encourage use of the cite element to refer to speakers in a conversation, or individuals when quoting them: | Opinions on whether HTML5 should explicitly permit and encourage use of the cite element to refer to speakers in a conversation, or individuals when quoting them: | ||
<div class="discussion"> | <div class="discussion"> | ||
| Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
* +1 [[User:Tcaspers|Tomas Caspers]] | * +1 [[User:Tcaspers|Tomas Caspers]] | ||
* +1 [[NickFitz]] | * +1 [[NickFitz]] | ||
* +1 [[User:Asbjornu|Asbjørn Ulsberg]] | |||
</div> | </div> | ||
Revision as of 11:54, 11 December 2009
Research, data, use cases, issues, and enhancements related to the HTML5 cite element.
speaker
The cite element has been used (and recommended to be used) to refer to speakers in a conversation, or individuals when quoting them, thus HTML5 should explicitly permit and encourage this use.
This section serves to document both uses in the wild, and long-standing recommendations/documentations thereof.
examples in the wild
- 2003-08-23: Won’t somebody please think of the gerbils? by Mark Pilgrim:
I mark up names of people I link to (like in the list above) with the CITE tag, and I have a script that runs every night that aggregates those tags and creates posts by citation.
- transcript of the presentation “What Brian Cant Never Taught You About Metadata”, by Drew McLellen (this is from a template I provided the transcription company; all others are similar structure. brucel)
- Many blog posts on adactio.com, e.g Blame from 2008-01-09:
...something Bruce Sterling said at last year’s South by Southwest...
- Default WordPress theme ("Kubrick") uses cite for name of commenters. That's approx 46 bajillion instances.
- The transcripts for comics (#34 and onward) at CSSquirrel. The links to the transcripts are hidden from sighted users, one example is: Transcript #35 2009-09-08
- 2005-05-16: Speakers in this Towneley Lazarus play edition are identified using CITE.
- Testimonials on the website for Go Figure Inc. use cite to denote the names/locations of the people who provided the testimonial
- Podcast transcript from dConstruct 2009 (more)
- Various "conversations"/transcripts at Petroglyphs, e.g. dialogue, and CSS classes defined for terms, titles, etc. (XMDP)
- any article at Einfach für Alle (major german accessibility resource), e.g. [1] (see sidebar, 4th box from top labelled "mehr dazu:") uses cite to mark up authors' names
documentation
- 1998-04-24 HTML 4.0 REC
Contains a citation or a reference to other sources.
As <CITE>Harry S. Truman</CITE> said,
<Q lang="en-us">The buck stops here.</Q>More information can be found in <CITE>[ISO-0000]</CITE>.
- 1999-12-24 HTML 4.01 REC (same definition and examples as quoted above).
- 2005-03-13: The Elements of Meaningful XHTML presentation (to an overflowing room at SXSW Interactive 2005 in Austin, TX) specifically, slide10 and following document blog quote markup, and slide 19 and following document conversation markup.
- 2005-09-29: update: The Elements of Meaningful XHTML presentation (to a packed room at Web Essential 05 in Sydney Australia) again slide 10 and following, and slide 34 and following respectively.
- ...
Opinions
Opinions on whether HTML5 should explicitly permit and encourage use of the cite element to refer to speakers in a conversation, or individuals when quoting them:
- +1 HTML5 Super Friends, specifically cite element: review of data.
- +1 Tantek
- +1 Jeremy Keith
- Bruce Lawson, article agreeing with Tantek, July 06 Breaking news: w3c specs are not the Word of God
- +1 Kyle Weems
- +1 Erik Vorhes
- +1 Matt Harris
- -0 EdwardOConnor
- +1 Tab Atkins Jr.
- +1 Citing in HTML5 by Rachel Moore
- +1 Tomas Caspers
- +1 NickFitz
- +1 Asbjørn Ulsberg