Component Model Discussion: Rendering - Revision history

Rolandsteiner: /* Rendering */ fix some copy/paste typos

2012-01-12T02:40:42Z

Rendering: fix some copy/paste typos

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:40, 12 January 2012
Line 154:		Line 154:
	\| R-------------------------------------+ \|		\| R-------------------------------------+ \|
	\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|		\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|
	\| [A,0] \| [S,0] \| \| [S,1] \| \| [S,2] \| [A,1] \|		\| [A,0] \| [R,0] \| \| [R,1] \| \| [R,2] \| [A,1] \|
	\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|		\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|
	\| +-------------------------------------+ \|		\| +-------------------------------------+ \|

Rolandsteiner: /* [F2] neither host element nor shadow root rendered, shadow root has single child <R> as root element */

2011-10-21T04:26:57Z

[F2] neither host element nor shadow root rendered, shadow root has single child <R> as root element

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:26, 21 October 2011
Line 148:		Line 148:

	=== [F2] neither host element nor shadow root rendered, shadow root has single child <R> as root element ===		=== [F2] neither host element nor shadow root rendered, shadow root has single child <R> as root element ===

			Similar to [F], but the ShadowRoot doesn't have to be an element itself, can be extended towards [G] later on.

	A-----------------------------------------------------+		A-----------------------------------------------------+

Rolandsteiner: /* Current State */

2011-10-21T04:12:55Z

Current State

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:12, 21 October 2011
Line 184:		Line 184:

	Currently we implemented variant [D].		Currently we implemented variant [D].

			We probably want to go towards [F2].

Rolandsteiner: /* [F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root */ add variant for [F]

2011-10-21T04:00:12Z

[F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root: add variant for [F]

@@ Line 145: / Line 145: @@
 Issues:
-* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.
+* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on &lt;x-foo&gt; are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.
 === [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===

Rolandsteiner: /* [F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root */ Fix incorrect statement about DOM positions

2011-10-21T01:58:21Z

[F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root: Fix incorrect statement about DOM positions

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:58, 21 October 2011
Line 138:		Line 138:
	\| SR------------------------------------+ \|		\| SR------------------------------------+ \|
	\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|		\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|
	\| ~~???~~ \| [S,0] \| \| [S,1] \| \| [S,2] \| ~~???~~ \|		\| [A,0] \| [S,0] \| \| [S,1] \| \| [S,2] \| [A,1] \|
	\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|		\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|
	\| +-------------------------------------+ \|		\| +-------------------------------------+ \|
Line 146:		Line 146:

	* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.		* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.
	* The potential gaps between the rectangles of the shadow root and the host element's parent don't directly map to a DOM position.

	=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===		=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===

Rolandsteiner: /* [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered */ simplify DOM position text

2011-10-05T04:04:58Z

[G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered: simplify DOM position text

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:04, 5 October 2011
Line 162:		Line 162:
	* There is no single rendering rectangle corresponding to <x-foo>.		* There is no single rendering rectangle corresponding to <x-foo>.
	* Containing document can't style the host element. Styles set on <x-foo> could be forwarded to ALL children of the shadow root, but it's not clear this is useful.		* Containing document can't style the host element. Styles set on <x-foo> could be forwarded to ALL children of the shadow root, but it's not clear this is useful.
	* The potential gaps between the rectangles of the shadow root's children and ~~the rectangle containing~~ the host element don't directly map to a DOM position.		* The potential gaps between the rectangles of the shadow root's children and the host element's parent don't directly map to a DOM position.

	=== [Z] Other? ===		=== [Z] Other? ===

Rolandsteiner: /* [F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root */ remove 'outer'

2011-10-05T04:04:27Z

[F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root: remove 'outer'

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:04, 5 October 2011
Line 146:		Line 146:

	* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.		* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.
	* The potential gaps between the rectangles of the shadow root and the ~~outer~~ host element's parent don't directly map to a DOM position.		* The potential gaps between the rectangles of the shadow root and the host element's parent don't directly map to a DOM position.

	=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===		=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===

Rolandsteiner: /* [F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root */ copy/paste DOM position text

2011-10-05T04:03:43Z

[F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root: copy/paste DOM position text

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:03, 5 October 2011
Line 146:		Line 146:

	* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.		* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.
	* ~~positions outside~~ the ~~ShadowRoot rect, but within~~ the host element		* The potential gaps between the rectangles of the shadow root and the outer host element's parent don't directly map to a DOM position.

	=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===		=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===

Rolandsteiner: /* [F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root */ correct fact that DOM positions in this variant also are unclear

2011-10-05T04:03:00Z

[F] host element not rendered, rendered shadow root: correct fact that DOM positions in this variant also are unclear

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:03, 5 October 2011
Line 138:		Line 138:
	\| SR------------------------------------+ \|		\| SR------------------------------------+ \|
	\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|		\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|
	\| ~~[A,0]~~ \| [S,0] \| \| [S,1] \| \| [S,2] \| ~~[A,1]~~ \|		\| ??? \| [S,0] \| \| [S,1] \| \| [S,2] \| ??? \|
	\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|		\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|
	\| +-------------------------------------+ \|		\| +-------------------------------------+ \|
Line 146:		Line 146:

	* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.		* Containing document can't style the shadow host. Because of Isolation it also can't style the ShadowRoot, unless styles styles set on <x-foo> are forwarded somehow. If so, mechanism of style forwarding needs to be specced.
			* positions outside the ShadowRoot rect, but within the host element

	=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===		=== [G] neither host element nor shadow root rendered ===

Rolandsteiner: /* Overview */ clarify DOM positions

2011-10-04T07:22:22Z

Overview: clarify <x-foo> DOM positions

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:22, 4 October 2011
Line 14:		Line 14:
	and as a somewhat lesser concern:		and as a somewhat lesser concern:

	[3] ~~every~~ point between the rectangles should correspond to a valid DOM range		[3] Every point between the rectangles should correspond to a valid DOM range.

			ad [3]: Note that conversely, in no variant there is a mapping from a DOM range with anchor <x-foo> to a rectangle/screen position, since the children of <x-foo> may be rendered in arbitrary places, depending on <content> elements within the shadow DOM, or even not at all.

	== Rendering ==		== Rendering ==

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:40, 12 January 2012
Line 154:		Line 154:
	\| R-------------------------------------+ \|		\| R-------------------------------------+ \|
	\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|		\| \| Y------+ Z------+ \| \|
	\| [A,0] \| [S,0] \| \| [S,1] \| \| [S,2] \| [A,1] \|		\| [A,0] \| [R,0] \| \| [R,1] \| \| [R,2] \| [A,1] \|
	\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|		\| \| +------+ +------+ \| \|
	\| +-------------------------------------+ \|		\| +-------------------------------------+ \|